| View previous topic :: View next topic | 
	
	
		| Author | Message | 
	
		| SOMAMASTER 
 
 
 Joined: 29 Apr 2011
 Posts: 1
 
 
 | 
			
				|  Posted: Fri Apr 29, 2011 3:10 pm    Post subject: Dual (2)answers to sudoku ??? Is it possible??? |   |  
				| 
 |  
				| I was doing a Sudoku from a book and my answere was correct and the published answer was correct. This is the first time this happened. Is it possible to have two correct answers to a puzzle.    |  | 
	
		| Back to top |  | 
	
		|  | 
	
		| Marty R. 
 
 
 Joined: 12 Feb 2006
 Posts: 5770
 Location: Rochester, NY, USA
 
 | 
			
				|  Posted: Fri Apr 29, 2011 3:57 pm    Post subject: Re: Dual (2)answers to sudoku ??? Is it possible??? |   |  
				| 
 |  
				|  	  | SOMAMASTER wrote: |  	  | I was doing a Sudoku from a book and my answere was correct and the published answer was correct. This is the first time this happened. Is it possible to have two correct answers to a puzzle.    | 
 There are people here who know a lot more about this than I do, but yes, it's possible to have two answers. However, most published puzzles have one unique solution, so it's possible that even though you had a correct solution per Sudoku rules, you didn't have the answer the puzzle constructor had in mind.
 |  | 
	
		| Back to top |  | 
	
		|  | 
	
		| Pat 
 
 
 Joined: 23 Feb 2010
 Posts: 207
 
 
 | 
			
				|  Posted: Sun May 01, 2011 8:18 am    Post subject: |   |  
				| 
 |  
				|  	  | SOMAMASTER wrote: |  	  | I was doing a Sudoku from a book
 and my answere was correct
 and the published answer was correct.
 
 Is it possible to have two correct answers to a puzzle?
 | 
 two answers,
or more,
 surely possible
 but hardly desirable.
 
could you please tell us which book this is?
 and post the puzzle as printed?
 |  | 
	
		| Back to top |  | 
	
		|  | 
	
		| lundbf 
 
 
 Joined: 06 May 2012
 Posts: 3
 
 
 | 
			
				|  Posted: Sun May 06, 2012 10:56 pm    Post subject: Two answers to my sudoku puzzle |   |  
				| 
 |  
				| I, too, had an answer that was different than the published solution with a sudoku puzzle from"Super Sudoku Puzzles" Vol 10 published by Kappa.  Since I have never heard of this happening before, I was wondering if I can post the unsolved puzzle, my solution and the published solution.  If this is permissible, what is the best way to do this?  Is it possible to post images?[/img] |  | 
	
		| Back to top |  | 
	
		|  | 
	
		| Marty R. 
 
 
 Joined: 12 Feb 2006
 Posts: 5770
 Location: Rochester, NY, USA
 
 |  | 
	
		| Back to top |  | 
	
		|  | 
	
		| lundbf 
 
 
 Joined: 06 May 2012
 Posts: 3
 
 
 | 
			
				|  Posted: Mon May 07, 2012 12:21 am    Post subject: Never Mind |   |  
				| 
 |  
				| I found the reason why they were different.  I had written out a duplicate of the puzzle after the first was wrong.  One the duplicate, I forgot to include one of the printed numbers.  It is very interesting how the absence of one number can allow for a totally different working answer... essentially one number juxtaposed between two boxes. |  | 
	
		| Back to top |  | 
	
		|  | 
	
		| lundbf 
 
 
 Joined: 06 May 2012
 Posts: 3
 
 
 | 
			
				|  Posted: Mon May 07, 2012 12:24 am    Post subject: Thank you |   |  
				| 
 |  
				| Thanks for your response!  I see how to place a grid in a non HTML format, thanks to your posting. |  | 
	
		| Back to top |  | 
	
		|  | 
	
		|  |